by Eric Simmons, FEMA Region 9
My grandfather would say “use the right tool for the job” as we pulled many a coup in the workshop. The right tool rule can also refer to communications as using a flood map for purposes which it was never intended is fraught with risk. Similarly, using the right map incorrectly or adapting an unfit one to mimic the performance of the correct map is problematic.
State law effective May 1, 2022, requires real estate transaction disclosure in the area exposed to rising ocean levels. Properties affected are those within 3.2-foot sea level rise projections by 2050. An interactive mapping tool, screenshot for Waikiki below, supports adaption to sea level rise around Hawaii as well as risk communication associated with ocean changes.
Another new online tool is Risk Factor where residents can learn a property’s flood and wildfire hazard and changes in risk over time. Estimates of the cost of flood damage are provided using property data, hazard estimates, and depths of flooding reaching buildings. To simplify risk communication, Flood Factors generates a 1 to 10 score for each property.
Properties with a higher score (Flood Factor of 9 or 10) face extreme risk and are more likely to flood. According to First Street Foundation, more than 30% of all Hawaiian properties face extreme to major flood risk today and losses in the future are increasing. The Flood Factor scores, represented graphically by buildings below, are also provided on Redfin, Realtor.com, and Estately websites.
Flood Insurance Rate Maps, or FIRMs, are hazard maps published to support the National Flood Insurance Program. They show zones of high flood hazard (for example, Zones AE, AO and VE as seen above) as well as medium, low and unknown flood hazard areas. These flood zones can be viewed on Hawaii’s Flood Hazard Assessment Tool (FHAT). FIRMs are used to manage new development in floodplains and advance other flood loss reduction activities. They help lenders determine who are required to purchase flood insurance. FEMA has initiated an island wide restudy of flood hazards for Honolulu. More information on FIRMs is available online.
Tsunami evacuation maps identify areas that may be impacted by an upcoming event and must be evacuated under a warning. Hawaii residents and visitors can determine if they’re in a tsunami evacuation zone by checking their phone book or going online to the FHAT. For Honolulu, the tsunami mapping now has an extreme evacuation zone. Similarly, the State Dam Safety Program provides on the FHAT if a property is in a dam failure evacuation zone. Tsunami evacuation zones, as seen for Waikiki below, are established by each Hawaiian County in conjunction with State public safety officials. These maps are available online on a tsunami viewer.
Evacuation maps are not inundation maps, like a Flood Insurance Rate Map or hurricane storm surge inundation maps. These storm surge maps for Hawaii are viewable on a NOAA Viewer. The following screenshot shows expected storm surge and inundation depths from a Category 4 hurricane.
A major difference between evacuation maps and FIRMs are the FEMA hazard zones being based on flooding with a specific probability of occurring. 1% annual chance water elevations are a statistical measure and vary in height throughout a community. Therefore, a 1% annual chance floodplain should not be directly related to a particular hurricane category or tsunami without extensive analysis. Further comparison of these different flood maps is in the table.
|Sea Level Rise Exposure Area||Flood Factor||Flood Insurance Rate Maps||Tsunami Evacuation Zones||Storm Surge Maps|
|Purpose of Map||Online atlas to support disclosure and vulnerability / adaptation to sea level rise as mandated by State law||Understand current conditions flood hazards and how flood risk changes over time||Determination of what structures may require flood insurance and development criteria / floodplain management||Information to plan for evacuation during a tsunami or tropical storm||Identify land flooded by a hurricane. A category 4 hurricane is like Hurricane Iniki in 1992|
|Map Source||Pacific Island Ocean Observing System (PacIOOS)||First Street Foundation||Federal Emergency Management Agency||County with data developed by the State of Hawaii||National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration|
|Types of Floods Depicted||An aggregate of 3 layers with sea level rise: passive flooding (still water high tide flooding), annual high wave flooding (over wash during the largest wave events of the year), and coastal erosion||Existing conditions and future flooding from rivers, rainfall and the oceans covering sizes from nuisance flooding to once-in-a-millennium.||Riverine and coastal flooding due to tropical storms, heavy rainfall, and –in some areas– tsunami or levee failure. Flood zones are based on the 1% annual chance (100-year) event and, where available, the 0.2% annual chance (500-year) event.||Tsunami||Category 1, 2, 3 or 4 hurricanes with storm surge depths|
|Information on Map||Sea Level Rise Exposure Area (SLR-XA)||Grids attributed with inundation probability and flood depths associated with time (year 2020 and 2050).||Flood insurance zones, regulatory floodways, cross section and transect locations, base flood elevations or depths, hydraulic structures, etc.||Evacuation areas impacted by tsunami||Storm surge flooding for each hurricane category. Inundation areas subdivided by flood depth.|
It is important to note that all five of these flood maps are not real-time products. For active flooding or tropical cyclones, please go online and consult local products issued by the National Weather Service. Prevention is the best protection and always use the right tool for the job.